In a recent development, Apple has submitted a cert petition to the Supreme Court, requesting that it reconsider a previous ruling in its ongoing battle with Epic Games. The case revolves around the App Store’s payment rules and whether they violate federal antitrust laws.
Background on the Dispute
For those unfamiliar with the dispute, let’s take a brief look at how things have unfolded so far. In 2020, Epic Games filed a lawsuit against Apple, alleging that the company’s control over app distribution and in-app purchases constitutes an abuse of its dominant market position. Specifically, Epic Games argued that Apple’s strict payment rules, which force developers to use Apple’s own payment processing system (and give it a 30% cut), stifle competition and limit consumer choice.
The Original Ruling
In August 2021, a federal judge ruled in favor of Epic Games, stating that Apple does indeed engage in anticompetitive behavior. The court also issued an injunction that would have forced Apple to allow app developers to point their users toward alternative payment options beyond the App Store.
The Impact of the Injunction
However, the injunction remains in limbo as Apple and Epic Games seek to elevate their battle to the high court. If the Supreme Court declines to take on the case, the injunction would go into effect, effectively changing the rules of the App Store. But what exactly does this mean for app developers?
The Breathtakingly Broad Impact
Apple has criticized the original ruling as "breathtakingly broad" because it would apply not just to Epic Games but to all app makers on the United States storefront. According to Apple’s petition, "In this single-plaintiff case, the district courtsua sponteissued a universal injunction prohibiting petitioner Apple Inc. from enforcing one of its contractual guidelines against all developers of apps on the App Store’s United States storefront — of which there are millions — not just against respondent Epic Games, Inc."
The Ninth Circuit’s Decision
In September 2022, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the original ruling, stating that extending injunctive relief to non-parties (approximately 100 other app developers) was necessary to redress Epic’s alleged injury. However, neither court ever found or considered whether relief as to all affected non-parties was necessary or appropriate.
Epic Games’ Counterpetition
Meanwhile, Epic Games has also filed its own petition to the Supreme Court, asking the high court to revisit its core allegation: that Apple violates federal antitrust laws with its lucrative App Store business. While the lower courts did side with Epic on the matter of promoting external payment options, the lion’s share of the ruling came down in Apple’s favor.
The Implications
If the Supreme Court ultimately decides to take on the case and reverses the original ruling, it could have significant implications for app developers. The App Store would remain intact, but developers would no longer be required to use Apple’s payment processing system. This change could lead to increased competition and a wider range of payment options for consumers.
Possible Outcomes
If the Supreme Court declines to take on the case or reverses the original ruling, we can expect several outcomes:
- The App Store will continue with its current payment rules.
- Developers may be allowed to point their users toward alternative payment options beyond the App Store.
- The antitrust laws surrounding app distribution and in-app purchases may be clarified.
Conclusion
The ongoing battle between Apple and Epic Games has significant implications for the tech industry. As the Supreme Court weighs its decision, we’ll keep a close eye on developments and provide updates as more information becomes available.
What’s Next?
As the case continues to unfold, we can expect further court proceedings and potential appeals. The outcome will have far-reaching consequences for app developers, consumers, and the tech industry as a whole.
In conclusion, Apple’s petition to the Supreme Court marks another chapter in the ongoing saga between Epic Games and Apple. As the high court weighs its decision, one thing is clear: the fate of the App Store and its payment rules hangs in the balance.
Related Articles
- Epic Games vs. Apple: A Guide to the Ongoing Battle
- Apple’s Antitrust Lawsuit with Epic Games: What You Need to Know
Subscribe for Updates
Stay up-to-date on the latest news and developments in the tech industry by subscribing to our newsletter.
